Words and knowing
The Dao De Jing says the name that can be named is not the eternal name (chapter 1), those who know do not speak (chapter 56), true words are not beautiful (chapter 81), and knowing that you do not know is best (chapter 71).
The book begins with the limit of words: “The name that can be named is not the eternal name.” It comes back to the point many times. When the Way is spoken, “it is bland and has no flavor” (chapter 35), and in chapter 25 the speaker does not know its name and only labels it the “Way”. Chapter 56 says it most briefly: “Those who know do not speak; those who speak do not know.”
From this follows a preference for few words. The sage “carries out unspoken guidance” (chapter 2), and chapter 43 says of “Teaching without words” that “few in the world attain” it. “To speak little is natural” (chapter 23, 希言); the best ruler “is sparing with his words” (chapter 17); “Describing its extremes leads to exhaustion” (chapter 5). The Way of heaven “does not speak, yet is good at answering” (chapter 73). Words are also distrusted for their polish: “Fine words can be sold” (chapter 62), “Light promises always earn little trust” (chapter 63), “great eloquence seems to stammer” (chapter 45), and the last chapter opens: “True words are not beautiful; beautiful words are not true.”
Knowing is treated the same way. “Pursuing learning, one gains every day; pursuing the Way, one loses every day” (chapter 48); “Get rid of ‘learning’ and there will be no anxiety” (chapter 20); the sage “learns not to learn” (chapter 64). When “intelligence is manifest” (智慧), there “arises great deception” (chapter 18), and chapter 65 says “People are hard to govern because they are too clever.” Against this the book sets another kind of knowing: “knowing yourself is clarity” (chapter 33), “Knowing this constant is called brilliance” (chapter 16), and the sage “knows without going” (chapter 47).
Chapter 71 joins the two threads: “To know that you do not know is best; not to know, yet think you know, is a sickness.” Chapter 70 says its own words “are very easy to understand and very easy to practice,” yet “no one in the world can understand them,” and ends on the sage who “wears coarse cloth but carries jade inside.” Chapter 78 names the manner of such words: “True words seem contrary.”
| Chapter | What it says |
|---|---|
| Chapter 1 道可道非 | The name that can be named is not the eternal name. |
| Chapter 2 天下皆知 | The sage carries out unspoken guidance. |
| Chapter 3 不尚贤使 | The sage keeps the people without knowledge and the clever from daring to act. |
| Chapter 5 天地不仁 | Many words lead to exhaustion; holding the center is better. |
| Chapter 16 致虚极守 | Knowing the constant is brilliance, and not knowing it leads to harm. |
| Chapter 17 太上下知 | The best ruler is sparing with his words. |
| Chapter 18 大道废有 | When intelligence appears, great deception follows. |
| Chapter 19 绝圣弃智 | Abandoning wisdom benefits the people, and words alone cannot say what to hold to. |
| Chapter 20 绝学无忧 | Getting rid of learning ends anxiety. |
| Chapter 23 希言自然 | To speak little is natural. |
| Chapter 25 有物混成 | The speaker does not know its name and only labels it the Way. |
| Chapter 27 善行无辙 | A good speaker leaves nothing to rebuke. |
| Chapter 33 知人者智 | Knowing others is wisdom; knowing yourself is clarity. |
| Chapter 35 执大象天 | Spoken, the Way is bland and has no flavor. |
| Chapter 38 上德不德 | Foreknowledge is the flower of the Way and the beginning of folly. |
| Chapter 41 上士闻道 | The lesser scholar laughs at the Way, and if he did not, it would not be the Way. |
| Chapter 43 天下之至 | Few in the world attain teaching without words. |
| Chapter 45 大成若缺 | Great eloquence seems to stammer. |
| Chapter 47 不出户知 | The farther one goes, the less one knows, and the sage knows without going. |
| Chapter 48 为学日益 | Pursuing learning gains every day; pursuing the Way loses every day. |
| Chapter 56 知者不言 | Those who know do not speak; those who speak do not know. |
| Chapter 62 道者万物 | Fine words can be sold. |
| Chapter 63 为无为事 | Light promises earn little trust. |
| Chapter 64 其安易持 | The sage learns not to learn. |
| Chapter 65 古之善为 | The ancients kept the people simple, and governing with cleverness robs the state. |
| Chapter 66 江海所以 | To be above the people, one must speak as one below them. |
| Chapter 70 吾言甚易 | These words are easy to understand, yet no one in the world understands them. |
| Chapter 71 知不知上 | To know that you do not know is best. |
| Chapter 72 民不畏威 | The sage knows himself but does not show himself. |
| Chapter 73 勇于敢则 | The Way of heaven does not speak, yet is good at answering. |
| Chapter 78 天下莫柔 | True words seem contrary. |
| Chapter 81 信言不美 | True words are not beautiful, and those who know are not learned in everything. |
Every line on the theme
Chapter 1
-
道可道非常道,
The way that can be followed is not the eternal Way.
-
名可名非常名。
The name that can be named is not the eternal name.
Chapter 2
-
是以圣人处无为之事,
Thus the sage puts himself in a position of non-active productive state,
-
行不言之教,万物作焉而不辞,
carries out unspoken guidance. The myriad things conform to the same law, without a word.
Chapter 3
-
常使民无知无欲,使夫智者不敢为也,
Always keep the people without knowledge and without desire, and make the clever ones not dare to act.
Chapter 5
-
多言数穷,不如守中。
Describing its extremes leads to exhaustion, and is inferior to holding the center (not naming).
Chapter 16
-
复命曰常,知常曰明,
Returning to life is called constant. Knowing this constant is called brilliance.
-
不知常,妄作,凶。
Not knowing the constant, acting arbitrarily, is harmful.
Chapter 17
-
悠兮其贵言。
Unhurried, he is sparing with his words.
Chapter 18
-
智慧出,有大伪;
When intelligence is manifest, arises great deception.
Chapter 19
-
绝圣弃智,民利百倍;
Reject the divine and abandon wisdom, the people will benefit a hundredfold.
-
此三者,以为文不足,
These above three, are insufficiently described by mere words,
Chapter 20
-
绝学无忧。
Get rid of "learning" and there will be no anxiety.
Chapter 23
-
希言自然。
To speak little is natural.
Chapter 25
-
吾不知其名,字之曰道,
I don't know its name. As a word, I label it the "Way".
-
强为之名曰大。
Imposing on it a name, I call it "great."
Chapter 27
-
善言无瑕谪,
a good speaker lacks flaws and rebuke,
Chapter 33
-
知人者智,自知者明。
Knowing others is wisdom; knowing yourself is clarity.
Chapter 35
-
道之出口,
But when the Way is spoken,
-
淡乎其无味。
it is bland and has no flavor.
Chapter 38
-
前识者,道之华而愚之始。
Foreknowledge is the flower of the Way and the beginning of folly.
Chapter 41
-
上士闻道,
When the superior scholar hears of the Way,
-
勤而行之;
he practices it diligently;
-
中士闻道,
when the average scholar hears of the Way,
-
若存若亡;
he half keeps it, half loses it;
-
下士闻道,大笑之。
when the lesser scholar hears of the Way, he laughs out loud at it.
-
不笑不足以为道。
If he did not laugh, it would not be the Way.
Chapter 43
-
不言之教,无为之益,
Teaching without words, the benefit of non-action:
-
天下希及之。
few in the world attain them.
Chapter 45
-
大辩若讷。
great eloquence seems to stammer.
Chapter 47
-
不出户,知天下;
Without going out of the door, one knows the world;
-
不窥牖,见天道。
without looking out of the window, one sees the Way of heaven.
-
其出弥远,其知弥少。
The farther one goes, the less one knows.
-
是以圣人不行而知,
So the sage knows without going,
-
不见而名,
names without seeing,
-
不为而成。
and achieves without acting.
Chapter 48
-
为学日益,为道日损。
Pursuing learning, one gains every day; pursuing the Way, one loses every day.
Chapter 56
-
知者不言,言者不知。
Those who know do not speak; those who speak do not know.
Chapter 62
-
美言可以市,尊行可以加人。
Fine words can be sold; noble deeds can raise a person up.
Chapter 63
-
夫轻诺必寡信,
Light promises always earn little trust;
Chapter 64
-
学不学,复众人之所过。
he learns not to learn, and brings people back from where they went too far.
Chapter 65
-
古之善为道者,非以明民,
Those of old who were good at the Way did not use it to make the people clever,
-
将以愚之。
but to keep them simple.
-
民之难治,以其智多。
People are hard to govern because they are too clever.
-
故以智治国,国之贼,
So to govern a state with cleverness is to rob the state;
-
不以智治国,国之福。
not to govern a state with cleverness is a blessing for the state.
Chapter 66
-
是以欲上民,必以言下之。
So to be above the people, one must speak as one below them;
Chapter 70
-
吾言甚易知,甚易行。
My words are very easy to understand and very easy to practice.
-
天下莫能知,莫能行。
Yet no one in the world can understand them, no one can practice them.
-
言有宗,事有君。
Words have an ancestor; deeds have a master.
-
夫唯无知,是以不我知。
It is because people do not understand this that they do not understand me.
-
知我者希,则我者贵。
Those who understand me are few; those who follow me are rare and precious.
-
是以圣人被褐怀玉。
So the sage wears coarse cloth but carries jade inside.
Chapter 71
-
知不知上,
To know that you do not know is best;
-
不知知病。
not to know, yet think you know, is a sickness.
-
夫唯病病,是以不病。
Only by recognizing the sickness as sickness are you free of it.
-
圣人不病,以其病病,
The sage is not sick, because he recognizes the sickness as sickness;
-
是以不病。
that is why he is not sick.
Chapter 72
-
是以圣人自知不自见,
So the sage knows himself but does not show himself,
Chapter 73
-
不言而善应,不召而自来,
does not speak, yet is good at answering; is not summoned, yet comes of itself;
Chapter 78
-
正言若反。
True words seem contrary.
Chapter 81
-
信言不美,美言不信。
True words are not beautiful; beautiful words are not true.
-
善者不辩,
The good do not argue;
-
辩者不善。
those who argue are not good.
-
知者不博,
Those who know are not learned in everything;
-
博者不知。
those learned in everything do not know.